Electric or hydraulic lift: how to choose

Both technologies move a car, but not in the same way, and they do not suit the same buildings. Here are the differences that matter.

SODILIFT editorial team · Understanding lifts · Reading time: 5 min

Electric or hydraulic lift: how to choose

How each works

The electric traction lift suspends the car and a counterweight from ropes or belts running over the sheave of a motor. The counterweight balances the car: the motor only has to move the difference in weight, which reduces the power needed.

The hydraulic lift pushes the car with a ram. A power unit, with its pump and oil tank, sends oil under pressure to go up; to go down, a valve lets the oil return to the tank.

The differences in practice

Electric tractionHydraulic
TravelLong, buildings with many floorsLimited, low-rise buildings
SpeedHigherLower
Machine roomNone in the machine-room-less versionPower unit next to the shaft, usually at the bottom
Heavy loadsYes, with long travelVery stable with heavy loads over short travel
Energy useLow, especially with gearless and a driveHigher: going up without a counterweight
Drift at landingsNoYes, corrected by re-levelling

When to choose electric

It is the default solution for residential buildings, offices and hotels. With a gearless motor and a frequency drive, it uses little energy, starts and stops smoothly and, in the machine-room-less version, frees all the space of the machine room.

When to choose hydraulic

It is justified mainly for heavy loads over short travel: industrial goods lifts, forklift loading, car lifts. Its power unit can sit next to the shaft, at the bottom, and it does not need much headroom at the top floor.

And for a replacement

In an existing building, the decision depends on what is already there: a reusable machine room, a sufficient pit, a hydraulic power unit in good condition. Many replacements switch from hydraulic to machine-room-less electric to save energy and space. We study it from your drawings and photos.

A reference to confirm, a project to study? Send us photos or drawings: we will reply with a proposal.

WhatsApp Contact

Frequently asked questions

Is a hydraulic lift cheaper?

For heavy loads over short travel it can be. In a multi-storey residential building, electric is usually the more balanced choice, including for energy use.

Can a hydraulic lift be replaced by an electric one?

Yes, in a full replacement, if the shaft allows it. We study the shaft, pit and headroom to confirm feasibility.

A lift project?

Send us your drawings: we study your project and send you a detailed offer.