Fuji or Yaskawa: which drive for an Edel K2 controller?

The choice does not depend on the drive brand, but on a simpler question: in a power cut, who brings the car back to the landing, the lift or the building?

SODILIFT editorial team · Technical notes for installers · Reading time: 6 min

Fuji or Yaskawa: which drive for an Edel K2 controller?

Why a drive

On a two-speed controller, the car switches from one speed to the other: the change can be felt. A frequency drive varies the speed continuously. Starting and stopping are gradual, levelling accuracy is better and the machine wears less.

It is also what makes gearless possible: a machine without a gearbox cannot run without electronic speed control.

Fuji FRENIC Lift: the rescue is in the lift

It is the drive around which Edel built its documentation: in the installation manuals, wiring is described with a Fuji FRENIC Lift, both in the 3VF manual and in the gearless manuals.

Its decisive advantage is automatic rescue. In a power cut, the controller brings the car to the nearest landing by itself and opens the doors, on its emergency supply (the UPS that Edel diagrams show at the drive input).

Second advantage: it works with both geared and gearless machines. One drive and one set-up logic, whatever the machine.

Yaskawa: the rescue depends on the building

The Yaskawa is specified in particular cases: installations with a machine room, for its value for money.

But it does not provide automatic rescue. In a power cut, bringing the car back to a landing no longer depends on the lift but on an emergency supply in the building: a generator, a UPS or a safety switchboard.

That is where the real decision is made. If the building has a reliable emergency supply, the Yaskawa does the job for less money. If it does not, or if it is not guaranteed, a power cut leaves the car between two floors, with its occupants.

The decision table

Fuji FRENIC LiftYaskawa
Automatic rescueBuilt into the liftNo, provided by the building
Geared machineYesYes
GearlessYesDepending on configuration
Machine roomWith or withoutUsually with
CostHigherBetter value for money
Edel documentation3VF and gearless manualsOutside the manuals

In other words: the extra cost of the Fuji buys independence from the building. It is a safety decision before it is a price decision.

Reading a controller designation

Three values matter in the designation of a controller with a drive: the voltage (400 V or 230 V), the current in amps and the motor power in kilowatts. All three are read on the motor rating plate; they cannot be deduced from the rated load or the number of floors.

Settings are not copied

A drive is not a part you replace and forget. The K2 643VF manual devotes a whole chapter to set-up: auto-tuning on the installed motor, adjusting the characteristic curve and configuring the parameters.

Auto-tuning makes the drive measure the real characteristics of the motor it is connected to. Copying the parameters of another lift as they are, even an identical one on paper, gives poor ride comfort and worse levelling accuracy. This commissioning is the technician's job.

A reference to confirm, a project to study? Send us photos or drawings: we will reply with a proposal.

WhatsApp Contact

Frequently asked questions

Can I copy the parameters from another drive?

It is not recommended. Auto-tuning measures the actual motor; copying parameters degrades comfort and levelling accuracy.

Which drive do you offer with the Edel Advanced controller?

We define it according to the installation: machine type, power, presence of a machine room and expected level of rescue.

A lift project?

Send us your drawings: we study your project and send you a detailed offer.